Double Standards on Double Screens As Face Unlock Comes to iPhone Duo

The age-old conflict between convenience and security rears its head (face?)

Sometimes you’re in a such rush to make a positive impression or correct a negative one, you get over your skis and end up showing cards you’ve held close to your vest until you’re ready to reveal them. That feels very much like what just happened with Apple unveiling Face Unlock for the iPhone Duo.

The FaceID logo from Apple

One of the criticisms of the iPhone Duo at its announcement and after its launch was the lack of FaceID, Apple’s secure way of allowing your mug to securely sign you into your iPhone. The lack of FaceID on the iPhone Duo became a theme, even though some of those critics have backed off of late. But Apple heard the complaints, and in the latest beta, iOS 27.3, Apple is bringing a lesser version of FaceID called Face Unlock to the iPhone Duo.

Suffice it to say some Mac and iPad users are confused at what appears (I stress the word appears) to be a software fix. Mac and some iPad users have been clamoring to unlock their devices in the way they can with their iPhones and iPad Pros for quite some time. The collected wisdom of the narrative nudgers is that there’s no room for the TrueDepth cameras to hide behind the slimmer displays of those devices. That may still be true. But Apple seems (I stress the word seems) to have blown the necessity for that camera assembly to quickly open the Duo out of the water by bringing Face Unlock to its new folding phone.

Face Unlock is not FaceID. It’s not as secure. The iPhone Duo doesn’t contain the TrueDepth camera the more secure FaceID requires. In fact, even with this change, you still have to use TouchID for password autofill and Apple Pay, and you have to have unlocked your iPhone recently. Even so, while it may be befuddling for others, it’s good news for iPhone Duo users. It also sorta, kinda, takes a whack at Apple’s security soapbox.

There’s obviously no hardware change to make this work, and I can’t speak to the differences between the camera assemblies beyond the lack of the TrueDepth camera in the Duo and those of other devices like the recent iPad mini 8 and the touchscreen MacBook. (I refuse to use the longer name.) But it sure feels like a move like this may have been hiding in plain sight for quite some time. Coming in the same beta release as Apple’s already announced new Full Disk Access controls it points to some interesting and possibly conflicting Cupertino points of view on security versus convenience coming to light under a new CEO.

Apple responded to this iPhone Duo criticism more quickly than I can remember it doing to anything since AntennaGate. Given that this appears to be a software fix It will be interesting to see if Apple follows that up by bringing Face Unlock to other devices that already use TouchID sooner rather than later.

Thanks for reading. You can subscribe to this blog if you care to. You can also find more of my writings on a variety of topics on Medium at this link, including in the publications Ellemeno and Rome. I can also be found on social media under my name as above. This site does not use affilate links.

 

The iPad mini 8: Thoughts and Observations

A short list of improvements that make a winning tablet even more of a winner

Remember the days when seemingly every product was advertised as “New and Improved!” Those were fun times. Apple has its own way of spinning that runs close enough to the parody border that it more often than not becomes white noise. For example, Apple trumpeted the latest update to the iPad mini as “its biggest update ever.” Thankfully, without exclamation points. The update is a good one. The best thing I can say about the iPad mini 8 is that it is still the same with a few very nice and welcome improvements. That won’t work as a marketing slogan and narrative nudger, but it works for the product.

The iPad mini 8 with an attached Apple pencil being held up and showing a screen with the text "The Same But Better!"

I mean that has a complete compliment and high praise. It’s not that I’m too set in my ways, but a key marker for the success of an upgraded device is how quickly I can get back to the work I was doing once a device is set up and if the improvements make a difference.

Everything that has made the iPad mini a key part of my toolkit is still there and Apple’s hardware iterations do up the iPad mini’s game. As well as the price. Except for that, I’m glad to see the changes. They are meaningful. More importantly, I’m glad Apple is still selling the device. Although you have to look hard on Apple’s website to find a mention of it, given everything else they are hyping this fall.

The improvements include adding an OLED display, more protection against water and dust, and making the device thinner while slightly expanding the display. The chips running the device graduated to the current generation with the one year shy of legal drinking age A20 shouldering the workload. Apple’s N1 wireless chip enables WiFi 7, Bluetooth 5, and Thread support, though that’s mostly future-proofing at this point. For cellular communication, Apple’s C2 modem is there for your cellular connectivity pleasure. The Center Stage camera used for FaceTime and other video calls has now moved to the landscape edge for better viewing angles.

All in all, it’s a good, short list for the small tablet, both today and for tomorrow. And a worthy list for what continues to be a worthy entry in Apple’s mobile computing lineup that often feels like it’s treated as a bastard stepchild.

OLED Display

The OLED screen looks lovely as OLED screens usually do. Bonus points for not having a bad pun or silly portmanteau in the name. I had no problems with the mini 7’s display, but this OLED version unquestionably creates a nicer viewing experience. The display is slightly larger and the bezels are slightly smaller. Coming from the iPad mini 7 to the mini 8 that size difference feels negligible.

In dark mode, blacks are blacker (handy in dark theaters where I work) and apps using darker colors get a bit more pop. (What is this fascination with black and white icons lately?) Handwriting with an Apple Pencil is just as smooth as it has been for several generations of the iPad line. Apple has nailed this and it’s good to see other apps like Marco Arment’s new app, Fineliner, (on the right below) taking advantage of it.

Many (too many in my opinion) were outraged that the display still only has a 60Hz refresh rate. I think any real disappointment with that depends on what you use the iPad mini for. In my use case it’s not an issue and I think some of the frustrations come from comparing too many spec sheets more than actually using the device. Narratives, good and bad, form in lazy ways.

A THINNER SLICE

The thinner device is indeed nicer to hold and carry. It’s not an earth-shattering difference, but it noticeably feels lighter in my hands. It’s enough of a difference that I still notice it after using the device for a week.

The iPad mini 8 stacked on top of the iPad mini 7The narrower width does make carrying the Apple Pencil attached to the magnetic charging port feel a little more precarious. Improving the water and dust resistance will certainly be a plus for those who use the device in environments more wet and dusty than I do. Although I wouldn’t bathe with it or bathe it in dust.

Do You Want Chips With That?

The chip and communication upgrades promise more efficiency, and the A20 offers more power to tap and performance to appreciate. I have noticed a performance boost in some of my work this week. If AI is your thing, the iPad mini is as ready as most of Apple’s other mobile devices are to handle those chores. More power to you.

Given the infrequency of iPad mini updates, bringing this edition into line with other current hardware means the iPad mini 8 will have a good life for several years to come. For those who use an iPad for more extensive or demanding work than I do, there is now more oomph in your hands.

As to the N1, I don’t have WiFi 7 but I’ve noticed a boost in WiFi performance and assume that it’s due to the NI chip given that there’s no change to my networking setup.

SOUND AND SPEAKERS

The one new feature that concerned me turns out not to be an issue. In order to improve the water and dust resistance Apple removed the speaker holes from the frame and placed the woofers under the screen with concealed the tweeters between the display glass and the aluminum enclosure for what Apple calls an Acoustic Display.

Since I watch content on the iPad mini quite a bit I was concerned about how that would affect sound quality and volume. To my ears there’s no discernible difference. Everything sounds fine. I just spent hours watching video audition submissions for my next directing project and things sounded like I expected. I was able to distinguish between the good and bad recordings with no issues.

I have seen and heard others say that they can feel the device vibrate a little when the volume is turned up loud. That makes sense to me given the design change, but I don’t typically run things anywhere close to full volume so I haven’t experienced this myself.

MY KIT AND HOW I USE IT

I purchased a Midnight colored (that would be black to most of the world that isn’t in marketing) iPad mini with 512GB of storage. I did not add on the Nano-texture display or cellular upgrades. Note that depending on which storage size you choose affects not only the price, but the chip configuration (binned or not, two Neural engines or one). I can’t speak to the differences, and I doubt we’ll ever see a review that compares one configuration to another.

As to my use case, at work I’m a theatre director. That’s the prism I view iPads through. I carry my scripts on an iPad Pro and an iPad mini, two different tools I use during different phases of the job. I import the scripts into GoodNotes and use an Apple Pencil to make notes on the script itself. I use Apple Notes to take rehearsal notes with the Apple Pencil as well. I’m a Slide Over fan, and I wish Apple would get rid of the unnecessary border around the Slide Over window.

An iPad mini 8 using Slide Over to reveal Apple Notes over a script that is highlighted in yellow

I’m constantly viewing and reviewing designs, documents, and communications throughout the pre-production and rehearsal process. Since the days of COVID, video auditions have become the predominant way for actors to submit prior to being called back for an in-person audition or callback, so there’s lots of video viewing there. When I’m not directing I use an iPad for streaming video entertainment, reading, and web browsing.

I was never in the now dwindling camp of iPad users that wanted to push the iPad more towards a Mac. I’m a believer in using the right tool for the job and am lucky enough to be able to stock my toolbox with the different computing solutions I need. iPads as they were and are fit my needs just fine. But the beauty of the iPad lineup as it currently stands is such that it can fill a lot more needs than I need it to and can be many different things to many different people.

I think you can extend that to Apple’s entire lineup of computing solutions. There are a variety of solutions that can fit a variety of needs, and none of them have to be everything for everybody. Unfortunately, Apple’s tools are increasingly even more expensive than they always have been. Indeed, the iPad mini 8 saw a price jump. But I’m a believer in the old clichés that you get what you pay for and that you should buy the best tools you need for the job at hand.

iPads have been so much a part of my theatre work that I’ve owned most of the lineup since the first iPad was introduced and I retired my Microsoft Tablet PCs. My current iPad Pro is an M4 version. I skipped the M5 version, but previously with both the Pro and iPad mini lineup I had been upgrading every cycle.

I’ve written about why I think the iPad is the perfect theatre rehearsal tool for a director many times before. And, I also see more actors using an iPad in rehearsal for their scripts. Though the majority I’ve seen are using an 11-inch model more than the iPad mini. I find that interesting given the comparable size comparison to the Samuel French and Dramatists scripts many actors are familiar with.

 A paperback script for The Lehman Trilogy side by side with an iPad mini 8 displaying the same script.

The Future and Now

As I mentioned earlier I alternate between the Pro and the mini for different stages of my work and even before this upgrade I found myself using the iPad mini in more scenarios than the Pro. Apple releases new versions of the iPad mini less frequently than the Pro. Given what looks like a broad curiosity about the iPhone Duo, I think any release cadence the iPad mini may have been on might change in the future depending on how things play out with the folding phone’s trajectory. That’s a script that’s still being workshopped.

I will say this. If Apple releases a foldable version of the iPad mini, I’d buy it in a heartbeat. Remember, the iPhone had its early beginnings in Apple planning for a touch tablet.

For the moment though, this year’s upgrades to the iPad mini have improved an already very good small tablet solution that will fill the various needs of those who use one today and for a few years to come. I hope that doesn’t come off as hyperbolic.

Thanks for reading. You can subscribe to this blog if you care to. You can also find more of my writings on a variety of topics on Medium at this link, including in the publications Ellemeno and Rome. I can also be found on social media under my name as above. This site does not use affilate links.

Apple’s Phone App Inconsistency Is Puzzling

On again, off again solutions aren’t fixes. But they demonstrate fissures.

Last year with the release of iOS 26 Apple loudly touted new changes to the Phone App to help users besieged by unwanted calls. I found the difference between the promise and the actual implementation to be confusing and wrote about it here.

A screenshot of an iPhone displaying a list of recent calls, with multiple entries highlighted in red and labeled as "Spam Risk."

I also wrote about it here last spring. My biggest gripe was that in order to truly banish an unwanted spam call that left a voicemail you needed to do so three times. Third times may be a charm, but no there’s no charm in this churn.

One of my hopes for iOS 27 was that Apple would use whatever AI magic it was conjuring behind the scenes in Cupertino to simplify the process. We all get way more spam calls and texts than we want. And yet, it still seemed like Apple was content to leave this as some sort of computer game requiring multiple taps to rid our phone logs of this unwanted nonsense. 

Well, so much for magical AI conjuring. The problems persisted with iOS 27. Or maybe it didn’t. Here’s the funny part. I’ve been on a kick about Apple’s consistent inconsistency of late. This latest twist gives new meaning to the concept of inconsistency.

With the release of IOS 27, I at first thought Apple had at least removed one of those three steps. After installing iOS 27 all I had to do was tap the little orange hand and the call disappeared from my call log as you can see in the video below.

Huzzah! Progress! Still, if that spammer had left a voicemail I had to manually delete that. But take small victories when you can.

Then, I noticed that it moved some, not all, of those calls I thought it had deleted to the Recents List. (See the first photo above.) That makes no sense. They were still marked as spam.

And then the real fun began.

What I thought was a fix became unfixed. It just stopped working somewhere along the line.  No longer did a tap on the orange hand delete the call from the log. It was back to the three-tap finger dance again.

And then it worked again.

And then it didn’t. 

And then it did. 

And…the glowering specter of inconsistency reared its ugly head again.

It’s been an on again/off again feature/bug/fix/annoyance since iOS 27 was released in September. It was working earlier this morning. For a while. Currently it is no longer working.

Perhaps at some point Apple and its AI wizards behind the scenes will straighten it out and deliver a real and lasting one-tap feature to banish all traces of unwanted spam calls that survives the perpetual beta life we’re all trapped in. I’m not holding my breath.

Apple wants to release products users will love. As long as carriers profit off of spam and spam still exists, the iPhone as a phone isn’t one of them when problems keep folding back in on themselves. We all know AI can’t fix greed or slovenliness. Call me crazy, but this seems like a tech problem AI could and should be used to fix.

Thanks for reading. You can subscribe to this blog if you care to. You can also find more of my writings on a variety of topics on Medium at this link, including in the publications Ellemeno and Rome. I can also be found on social media under my name as above. This site does not use affilate links.

Sounding Off On Apple’s Consistently Inconsistent Sound Routing Issues

The sounds of confusion

The one thing most of us strive for in life is some measure of consistency. The sphere of life doesn’t matter. When we can achieve some modicum of consistency in an inconsistent and inconstant world it’s a plus. That’s certainly true with whatever tech we surround ourselves with. Sadly, sometimes comically, the inconsistency is the only constant thing in these days of rapid technology changes. I’m not a fan.

A pair of white AirPods and a White HomePod mini

While this post is mostly about Apple sound issues relating to AirPods and HomePods, let me first point out a quote from this excellent post by Sean Heber called Where Are We Going?

So much of what I like(d) about computers is how or why they worked. The algorithms were clever. The “why” of many things could be reasoned about and understood if you knew the deeper principles upon which everything else was built. I had faith that the unknowable parts were still knowable even if I didn’t always have the will to dig that deeply myself. I trusted that anything I might need to know someday could be found and mastered if truly necessary.

As time has gone on, though, that faith has been tested and now, perhaps, it is truly broken.

I don’t think anyone knows how anything works anymore. Not really. The scale exceeds human comprehension.

Sums it up nicely in my opinion.

On to those AirPod and HomePod issues. I really enjoy my AirPods Pro 3. I use them all the time and have used every generation of AirPods since the first one. But how they connect and reconnect through my devices is has been an increasingly constant source of inconsistency and frustration.

I’ll go several weeks when everything works as magically as they are supposed to work, switching between devices effortlessly. Then all of a sudden that just stops. Connections will jump inexplicably from one device to another at the oddest times, or fail to connect with no rhyme or reason. Then, after some indeterminate period things will right themselves again.

Like Mr. Heber I don’t think anyone knows how any of this is supposed to work anymore. I highly suspect Apple doesn’t either.

My hunch doesn’t explain the reason for the inconsistent behavior, but I do believe it’s because we live in a perpetual beta season with changes constantly happening on our devices and behind the scenes that users are unaware of, can’t track down, and that any support source, including Apple’s, can keep up with.

I wrote this post for two reasons.

First, this morning I needed to set a timer. I was wearing my AirPods and Apple Watch and told Siri to do so. My AirPods told me the timer was set. The timer completed as intended. But the expired timer didn’t show on my Apple Watch, my iPhone, or my Mac. It was still chiming when my wife tracked it down on my iPad Pro at the other end of our apartment, which I hadn’t used since Saturday. Like I said, sometimes it’s comical.

Once I silenced the expired timer and was back at my desk I was scrolling through my feeds and noticed this review by Jennifer Pattison on The Verge of the HomePod mini 2. She mentions that the signature feature of being able to use HomePods as default speakers for a Mac was not working for her as designed.

Following that I stumbled on this MacRumors article by Tim Hardwick that some users are returning newly purchased HomePod mini 2s for the same problem Pattison experienced.

These are not new issues. HomePod users have reported AirPlay issues prior to all of the changes Apple is introducing this year. I have personally experienced these kind of connection issues with AirPods prior to any of this year’s rollouts. And that’s the problem. These changes are supposedly designed to make things work together seamlessly, but for some time now Apple’s sound routing issues with HomePods and AirPods inconsistently keep baring all of the seams in a system that’s great when it works, but keeps tripping over itself when it doesn’t.

I will say this. In my early days of using AirPods before things supposedly got better I experienced far fewer issues, though there were far fewer bells and whistles.

I don’t think it’s too much to ask to consistently hear bells or whistles where I asked them to be piped into my ears or the way they are advertised.

Thanks for reading. You can subscribe to this blog if you care to. You can also find more of my writings on a variety of topics on Medium at this link, including in the publications Ellemeno and Rome. I can also be found on social media under my name as above. This site does not use affilate links.

 

Apple’s Slew Of New Products Bode Well For A Broader Based Future Built On Niches

Choices are always a good thing

You can’t say Apple hasn’t been busy. That’s certainly the case given the slew of new products announced and released this fall, with some yet to still hit store shelves later this month. In some ways it feels like it’s an inventory clearing of hardware products that have been waiting for the software side of things to catch up. In some ways it points to a more diversified product lineup and broader user base in the future.

Apple PR Image of a young woman using a touch screen MacBook Pro with a city skyline at night in the background  c8gxlalyqeie large 2x.

Either way I’m glad to see products like the iPhone Duo and the insanely named MacBook PROLED XDR Display (I wonder if they used Apple Intelligence for that — I hope that’s the excuse) even though they aren’t products I’m interested in. I’m also glad to see familiar hardware form factors continue to receive incremental improvements. Although the price increases for some of the familiar home products will put them further out of the reach for many.

As for the iPhone Duo and… I’m just going to call it the MacBook Touch, these both look like specific niche products that time will tell if their respective niches will be big enough to warrant the initial investment. Regardless of what the bottom line future holds, my hunch is that they will each develop an ardent and passionate user base.

And that is as it should be.

Apple is not only broadening the number of products it sells, it is also broadening the number of ways users can interact with its products and its vision of computing. Apple is often criticized for its narrow and opinionated view of how computers and technology should work. That will still happen because Apple is indeed still opinionated and critics will always be critics. But it will happen within a larger universe of product possibilities that doesn’t feel quite as one size fits all or how one device in a category has to cater to every possible type of user.

As to the price point problem everyone in consumer tech is facing, I don’t think you have to look any further than the introduction of the NEO last spring to understand where Apple is headed. While those initial NEO prices have increased due to chip costs, and the next version will probably do the same, it looks to me that Apple is further segmenting, while still expanding its customer base by including a larger array of price point options.

I am thoroughly puzzled by the $299 price point of the Apple TV though. It seems oddly out of place. I, and several others I know were looking forward to upgrading that device this year. But at that price point most I’m talking to are, like me, sitting tight with what they currently have.

Going forward, a lot of the coverage is going to focus on the new and shiny iPhone Duo and MacBook Touch. That’s understandable. But I think the bigger story is going to be about the entire lineup and how those new products fit in and expand Apple’s user base.

Thanks for reading. You can subscribe to this blog if you care to. You can also find more of my writings on a variety of topics on Medium at this link, including in the publications Ellemeno and Rome. I can also be found on social media under my name as above. This site does not use affilate links.

 

Fondling Apple’s Folding iPhone Duo

First impressions leave a mark.

Anticipating Apple’s now released iPhone Duo I spent a morning earlier this past summer checking out Samsung’s latest folding smartphones. I’d never been interested in the folding form factor before and thought it was time to feel them out for myself. I wrote about that here. 

The iPhone Duo in close modeYesterday on a series of errands I convinced my wife to join me in doing some hands-on time with the iPhone Duo in a local Apple Store. Not only did I want to check the device out myself, but my wife is unflinching in her response to all things tech. Her responses are always genuine, occasionally surprising, and often unflinching. With her it’s a quick like/don’t like, and her first impressions rarely change even as she slowly adopts something new.

She was a reluctant iPhone user, only coming on board once manual keyboards disappeared from the scene. And her favorite iPhone was the iPhone mini. Even though she’s using an iPhone 17 now, she still curses Apple for discontinuing that form factor. Daily. Sometimes multiple times a day. I distinctly remember how unhappy she was the day she traded in the second of her iPhone 13 minis. 

Back in the day when video reviews of gadgets began to be a thing I’d put her in front of a camera for GottaBeMobile to see how she responded to things. The results were often hilarious as she’d make up her own terms for things, but in the end, always telling. 

Before I get to my initial reactions to fondling the device, let me say straight up my wife was not impressed. When she first picked up the device she emphatically said, “This is too heavy. I wouldn’t put that in my purse.”

A woman holding an iPhone Duo

Almost immediately followed by “What kind of case do you put on this thing?” She drives the tech she uses hard. So hard, I’m glad Apple Care exists. 

I encouraged her to fold and unfold the device, check out its different orientations and open a few apps. Her negative impression of the device’s weight paled in comparison to her reaction when she realized she couldn’t fully reach across the screen in the closed position to type on the keyboard with one hand. She could get close, but not close enough to feel comfortable. 

She was surprised at how difficult it was to open and close. “You have to use two hands to do anything on this,” she exclaimed. “I feel like I’m going to break it. For something so solid and heavy it feels too fragile.” 

First impressions leave a mark. Hers were as indelible as a tattoo. 

I have to admit mine were only different by degree.

Even though I’d read about how heavy the iPhone Duo is, I was surprised at the weight in my hand when I picked it up. Opening and closing the device needed more heft than I wanted it to, much like the Samsung devices I checked out this past summer.

While the premium builds of these foldable devices feel solid when you pick them up, the central premise and promise of unfolding the screen feels far too adventurous in my limited hands on time. I’ve noticed that some reviewers are searching for the right place to put your thumb on the larger screen when you close the device after the news of some screens cracking due to a hinge fault. To a degree it smacks of “you’re holding it wrong.” Or is that folding? There’s a Kenny Rogers gambling joke in there somewhere.

I very much like the larger display and can see its attractiveness. So much so that my gut feeling after reading and watching reviews was confirmed once I held the device. I wish Apple had released a folding iPad mini.

Though as someone who uses an iPad as a primary tool in theatre rehearsals, without a good case solution I find it hard to image using what is a very nice thin display in what can be a bit of a hectic and chaotic environment of tech tables filled with other equipment. But a suitable case solution defeats and diminishes the effect of this very nice smaller screen. At least in my mind. 

I’m not as enamored of the closed face. Again, in limited hands-on testing I agree with those who say there’s too little screen real estate when a keyboard is on the screen to feel comfortable. Everything feels crowded. Certainly not pleasing to the eye. 

All of that said I’ll say what I said about Samsung’s foldables. I can see the attraction for this category of smartphones. But it’s not something I’m interested in. Even ignoring the price points they feel more like luxury devices, than they do everyday practical devices. They require too much hands-on effort for those of us who’ve gotten used to the grab-and-go way we use our smartphones. I’m sure I could get used to quickly taking a photo with practice, but I bet it would still take longer than doing so on my current iPhone. My grandkids move too fast for that kind of action.

I also can’t imagine quickly folding and unfolding an iPhone Duo to take notes or review a script in rehearsals to avoid those chaotic tech tables. Moments move too quickly for an action that feels so painstaking.

These are first impressions. First impressions leave a mark and you don’t often get a chance to change them. Samsung and others have been attempting to reverse that trend for years now, and I imagine they hope Apple’s entry into the foldable market will be a big enough boost to help the entire segment. That may prove to be true down the road, but I think foldable smartphone makers still have some distance to travel before everyday users feel comfortable wrapping their hands around folding phones.

 One other quick note. Talking to an Apple store employee I’m familiar with they said interest quickly waned after a small rush on release day last Friday. My wife and I were the only two people anywhere near the two iPhone Duos the store had on display for the hour or so we were in the store, though admittedly it was on a Monday afternoon.

Thanks for reading. You can subscribe to this blog if you care to. You can also find more of my writings on a variety of topics on Medium at this link, including in the publications Ellemeno and Rome. I can also be found on social media under my name as above. This site does not use affilate links. 

 

The iPhone Duo and Lack Of Liquid Glass Seem Confusing To Me

A curious design choice or a clueless observer?

It’s been interesting to watch coverage of the new iPhone Duo. Regardless of how you feel about the device it is certainly something different and I dare say exciting to talk about.

Siri ai hero  c59xcl4s2n2a large 2x.I haven’t seen or fondled the device in person as of yet. I’m planning a trip to a local Apple Store at some point early this week to see and touch it for myself. I’m sure my reactions will be similar to most. It’s a cool new piece of tech that has some first generation issues.

Regardless of how that visit pans out, I still don’t think the device is something I’m interested in. Perhaps in a future evolution. Perhaps one that is a folding iPad mini without all of the phone guts. I’d find that appealing. I’m guessing we’re at least a couple of years off from Apple and the carriers finding a way to make the Handoff feature, that seems obviously designed to attract folks who might want to own both a traditional slab phone and a folding phone, work as smoothly as Apple wants it to be.  I certainly don’t want to pay for another phone line even as an add-on.

One thing I’ve noticed in reading and watching reviews is the right margin separation that Apple has segregated for the dock and controls, which I believe is the case in most orientations. I have seen images of some apps that also have controls on the left side when the device is open and showing two apps side-by-side. But that’s certainly not the case on the closed front screen. Even so, those I’ve seen seem to adhere to that separate toolbar (for lack of a better descriptor) approach. Apple chalks this up to a lack of vertical display space requiring these controls being located on the margins.

(See the update on the above below.)

When I look at it and hear complaints from others about how that leads to wasted space, it makes me wonder why the choice. Certainly in the context of what the original promise of Liquid Glass was all about. It just seems natural to me that any of those controls could overlay content in a liquidly-glassy sort of way. I’m not saying that would be ideal, but to my eye it sure seems logical.

I could be off base completely and there may be some tech or design reason I’m not understanding. Although I do note that there is talk (rumors?) that Apple is working on ways to make Safari feel less cramped, and give developers more freedom in designing their apps.

There’s an interesting article by Lavande that relates to this that might be worth your time if your’e as curious or clueless as I am.

The only thing I’m sure of is whatever the second generation of the iPhone Duo turns out to be, I bet we’re in for some changes given the excitement around the new device and both the positive and negative feedback Apple has received so far.

Update: I did take that trip to the Apple Store. And at least one Apple app, Maps, does look more like what I would expect apps (at least Apple’s) to look like with Liquid Glass with the controls overlaying the content. I’ll write up more about my iPhone Duo fondling experience in the next day or so.

 

Thanks for reading. You can subscribe to this blog if you care to. You can also find more of my writings on a variety of topics on Medium at this link, including in the publications Ellemeno and Rome. I can also be found on social media under my name as above. This site does not use affilate links.

 

Previews, Pre-Season, Betas, and Opening Nights

Some more thoughts on the iPhone Duo release with a dash of theatre and sports tossed in the mix

There’s an old saying in the theatre biz. No show is ever really ready on opening night. It’s a cliché that has seen it’s time pass in the big money commercial circuit because so many producers run lengthy preview weeks, charging essentially, but not quite, full price to avoid reviewers publishing their criticisms until the show is officially open. The preview process began lengthing after the days of out-of-town tryouts came to an end, although we see that still happening occasionally as larger regional theatres will debut a work, allowing it to still be worked on, hoping that it will one day make it to Broadway.

Apple iPhone Duo closed and open_big.jpg.large_2x.

There was a famous production of Eugene O’Neil’s play Hughie, starring and directed by Al Pacino, that ran in previews for almost a month before finally opening. That led to a critic from Daily Variety breaking the only after opening night embargo a week early since the announced limited run would end up with less “real” performances than those in previews after the show officially opened. The show would go on to extend the run a couple of times.

In smaller circuits the cliché still lives on, simply because of a lack of resources to run many preview performances in front of audiences to really gauge reaction before it officially opens. A show can look great in final dress rehearsals, but it’s never complete until there’s a paying audience of strangers sitting in the dark to tell if it works or not. The ever-present lack of time still breathes life into the cliché in ways that offer both hope and anxiety behind opening night curtains around the world.

In the professional sports world teams play in a pre-season or spring training games that don’t matter while the players tune up for the real thing. Although in most of those types of meaningless games it’s really more like watching players audition than it is anything else. Occasionally a budding star emerges, but that’s atypical. Early “real” season games that do count (at full price) are when teams find out what they have, leading knowledgeable sports viewers knowing when it is time to pay real attention to a team’s chances or not.

Those are two interests in my life. I’m a theatre professional (and geek) and I watch sports. Another is my interest in tech. In tech we have betas. Or we used to, when that was mostly for software. Now we’re just in previews, pre-season, or perpetual betas forever for both software and hardware. Which is somewhat understandable, yet weird, perhaps ironic, but ultimately a joke on the paying public, given the pace in which things are always advancing in tech, including the pace and price of advancement.

We never seem to reach opening night, opening day or the end of a beta period in tech. Instead products and software are released incomplete, occasionally followed immediately by “leaks” that suggest the company that just took your money for it’s latest best product ever is working on fixing the things they knew were wrong for the next version when they released the product you just payed for.

But you’re going to love it.

It’s easier to swallow with software. It’s a bigger pill that sticks in the craw with hardware.

It used to be that betas were for working out bugs. They still are to a degree, but now they’re just the next show in a never-ending season, or the latest minor-league call up. But you still pay full price for the game when the team needs to put a not ready for the big leagues pitcher on the mound just to fulfill its obligation to play the announced season.

You can argue that there’s nothing wrong with the way things have evolved in tech because the financial equations are different. It requires a substantial upfront investment to create, produce and deliver new technology. You’d be mostly wrong, but you can argue it. Most of the costs in show biz happen upfront before a show even gets close to an audience, hopefully a large enough one in a long enough run to recoup the initial investment. It is a different equation in sports.

The release of Apple’s iPhone Duo strikes me as an interesting entry in this evolution of consumer dynamics. Soon, perhaps too soon, before the product was released to the general public, leaks popped out that Apple was working on tweaks to two of the major criticisms of the device for the next generation — a larger model and adding FaceID. That followed criticism from reviewers.

In general, most tech reviews I read, watched, or listened to made it very clear that the iPhone Duo was a first generation device with some rough edges that wasn’t for everyone, especially at the entry price. I can’t judge those reviews myself since I haven’t seen the product, but they mostly seemed very similar and to my mind fair. Some, sounding more like theatre critics or sport writers I’ve known, were more harsh, delivering criticism that might have prompted a closing notice being posted before intermission or an early game benching.

Here’s where my three interests diverge a bit. In theatre the show can close early if it’s savaged or not enthusiastically endorsed by reviews. In sports a pro team can retool a bit by trading or signing free agents midseason. Tech companies have to play out the run with tech hardware until the next generation is ready.

Given the leaks following the reviews I find it sort of funny that I’m in a place of feeling a bit sorry for the carriers that are offering great deals on the iPhone Duo subsidized by a three year contract. That’s a tough sell to anyone who pays attention, though admittedly most won’t if they’re hot to trot for the new shiny folding phone from Apple.

It’s my hunch, and only a hunch, that Apple knew these criticisms were coming. Even so, it’s one thing to prepare the next version hoping to make changes that advance a platform, it’s another to make them in reaction to negative press once the product is unveiled. It sets you up in the next round for being congratulated for fixing what was wrong the last time.

In the theatre if a joke doesn’t land, you can replace the joke in previews. In sports you bench a player or fire a coach. With tech hardware it’s not that easy changing things before it becomes a punch line. (See the Vision Pro.)

My second hunch, only a hunch, is that the iPhone Duo will eventually become a successful part of Apple’s lineup and get past what feels like a rough opening. I don’t think it will enter into Vision Pro punchline territory. Critics of all human endeavors need something to criticize as much as companies need to produce the next thing. It’s a symbiotic relationship that feeds on itself. And the always distracted general public has short-term memory bordering on amnesia.

It’s my wish that tech companies, like theatre companies and sports teams, would figure out a better path to the success they seek. Sure, you might be able to fool some of the people all of the time. But for the most part folks figure it out on their own. Some of the time. And that some of the time is what everybody on the producing end of things counts on.

Thanks for reading. You can subscribe to this blog if you care to. You can also find more of my writings on a variety of topics on Medium at this link, including in the publications Ellemeno and Rome. I can also be found on social media under my name as above. This site does not use affilate links.

 

iPhone Duo Reviews Yield Few Surprises and A Preventable PR Faux Pas By Apple

The jury is still out after the early reviews break

When Apple introduced the iPhone Duo in September I called it “the ultimate wait and see device.” Folks have waited, and now some folks have seen, fondled, written and talked about it. Those who got lucky in the preorder lottery will see iPhone Duos tomorrow and quite a few will be waiting a bit longer given supply and demand issues. From most accounts I’d say there’s still a bit of waiting and seeing to come.

Apple iPhone Duo optimized apps Netflix 2_big.jpg.large_2x.

Generally reviewers were excited by the new device. Even if their comments about certain aspects were scathing. Of course none of them paid $2000+ for the review units. It will be interesting to see which ones do. But the excitement was tempered with many of the same questions folks had immediately following the introduction and the initial hands on impressions: The weight, reachability for left-handers, the small cover screen, the button placements, no FaceID, cameras, etc…

One of the big questions then and now, was how third party apps would work given the short lead time for developers to get their apps updated for the multiple screens and new layouts. More than a few weren’t ready for reviewers when they received their review unit. Several I read complained about this and warned that it was going to take a while for developers to catch up, leading to some subpar experiences. Again, that’s been said over and over since the Duo was introduced. Those reviews also mentioned how updated apps continued to roll out during the week that they had to check out the devices.

Intriguingly the day after the reviews dropped Apple popped out a press release touting the apps that will be ready when these devices make it into consumers’ hands or shortly thereafter. If you ask me that’s a sloppy unApple-like PR move that could have been avoided by having that info ready for reviewers. It wouldn’t have avoided all the words and talk about the issue, but it would have cast it in a different light. Apple never looks good when it’s playing catch-up. If that was a strategy, it was a poor one.

But that’s largely inside baseball in the way the gadget reviewing game is anyway. The real test will come when real users get their hands on the device and figure out how to hold it and work with it.

Below is a list of reviews I found interesting, mostly for their similarities. Again, pointing out questions or issues easily surmised after the Duo’s initial introduction.

That said, one interesting theme emerged in these reviews, from some subtextual, while others stated it bluntly: folks like the iPad-ness of the Duo’s larger unfolded screen quite a bit, with some wishing Apple had just created a folding iPad mini.

I find that thinking fascinating given my history with the iPhone. I stayed away from the first iPhone and didn’t get into what would become iOS until Apple released the iPod Touch later in 2007. I got on board the iPhone train with the 3GS. Keep in mind that the iPhone, as exciting as the early models were, didn’t really take off until the iPhone 4 and iPhone 5 generations.

The Verge: The iPhone Duo Is A Messy, Expensive Good Time.

The Wall Street Journal: iPhone Duo Review: Too Much IPhone, Too Little iPad

Tech Radar: I Spent A Week With the Apple IPhone Duo — And Yes, It Was Worth The Wait

Wired: Review: Apple iPhone Duo

9to5Mac: iPhone Duo Review: The Future Is Foldable

New Things With Joanna Stern: The Good, The Bad, and the Buggy

Daring Fireball: The iPhone Duo

As I’ve previously stated, I’m sitting on the sidelines and watching this all unfold. It’s still too early for me or anyone to draw any real conclusions. But based on what I’ve been reading and listening to, it sounds like next year’s Duo might be less of an expensive prototype than this first edition. We’ll understand better how the first iPhone Duo will fare about the time we start hearing rumors about the next one in January. Who knows? Maybe we’ll even see that folding iPad mini in a year or two.

Thanks for reading. You can subscribe to this blog if you care to. You can also find more of my writings on a variety of topics on Medium at this link, including in the publications Ellemeno and Rome. I can also be found on social media under my name as above. This site does not use affilate links.

 

Apple’s Coming Attractions

Will Apple deliver beyond the hype?

We’ve seen the trailers. We’re in the swirl of they hype storm. What the real story wil be is yet to unfold. Even so, some are declaring success before the first reel even kicks off. 

TIM261026 Apple Cover FINAL.

It’s not hard to see the excitement around the iPhone Duo, Apple’s folding iPhone, and the Homeview gadget meant to be used in your home by you and all of your very loud family members. Even so, Time Magazine’s cover story about The Best Inventions of 2026, featuring new Apple CEO John Ternus feels a bit premature.

I’m not poo-pooing what these new Apple devices may offer. No one knows. And that’s the point. I’ve got questions about both I want to see answered once the devices are in real users’ hands and how that all fits in with Apple’s philosophy about making the iPhone the center of your universe.

I especially have questions about the Homeview after seeing Apple’s video trailer for the device. That’s based on the fact that nothing I’ve seen so far in any OS with a 27 at the tail end of it works as fast as that bit of video makes you want to believe. Much less fast user switching. Siri AI may be improved, but it’s still feels slower than the non-AI version of a year ago. Perhaps an OS update will fix that at some point in the future. But these devices roll out sooner than that.

I’d love to see these new gadgets be winners and live up to the hype and the promises. That may indeed happen. I actually hope it does.

My hesitancy and skepticism is that I’ve yet to see Apple’s software come close to living up to that hype, much less the speed or efficiency I believe everyone wants. In fact, given that much of this is somehow connected via Apple’s flavor of AI, Apple Intelligence, I’ve yet to see any chatbot of any stripe deliver on that kind of promise consistently. And consistency is the key. Or at least should be.

But then again, all the world’s a beta these days.

Thanks for reading. You can subscribe to this blog if you care to. You can also find more of my writings on a variety of topics on Medium at this link, including in the publications Ellemeno and Rome. I can also be found on social media under my name as above. This site does not use affilate links.